Top 5 Pizza Places in St. Augustine

Grab a Slice of Pizza in Tropical Paradise

Nothing says “vacation relaxation” like a warm and cheesy slice of pizza from one of the best pizzerias in St. Augustine! Read the list below to get our top recommendations.

1. 180 Vilano Grill & Pizza

180 Vilano Grill & Pizza is a hidden gem of a family restaurant operated out of Vilano Beach. From its quaint, weathered exterior, you would never guess that they have fantastic pizza and calzone options, such as the succulent Greek pizza, the delicious spinach calzone, and a decadent seafood pizza. The generous portions are enough to feed your whole family!

Price Range: $10 – $30

11:00am – 9:30pm Daily 

2. Pizza Time

Prepared in a New York style, the pizza at Pizza Time is sure to impress even the staunchest of pizza territorialists (whether you’re loyal to the genre of pizza from the Big Apple or the Windy City). Their garlic knots are also a hit with the local crowd.

Price Range: Under $10

11:00am – 10:30pm Daily 

3. Carmelo’s

For a decent price, you can get a slice or a whole pizza pie at Carmelo’s. Tucked away behind Flagler College (and a convenience store), this pizzeria is a local secret. The portions are ridiculously huge, so come hungry and bring your friends and family to help!

Price Range: Under $10

11:00am – 10:00pm Sunday through Thursday  

11:00am – 11:00pm Fridays and Saturdays

4. Mellow Mushroom

From its funky decorations to its pizzas with groovy names like Kosmic Karma and Magical Mystery Tour, the Mellow Mushroom is truly a laid-back pizzeria. You can also build your own pizza with a host of sauce and topping options.

Price Range: $10 – $30

11:00am – 12:00am Sunday through Wednesday    

11:00am – 1:00am Thursday through Saturday

5. Five Star Pizza

No pizza joint delivers later than Five Star Pizza! Save this pizzeria for late nights lounging in your vacation home or condo, as it’s really more of a takeout or delivery shop than a sit-down restaurant. The thin-crust pizza is to die for, and people come from miles around just for the garlic knots alone!

Price Range: Under $10

10:00am – 3:00am Daily                    

The Ocean Gallery Knows the Ins and Outs of St. Augustine!

Just ask us for advice on planning your St. Augustine vacation itinerary when you contact us today to book your very own vacation home or condo and make your next trip the trip of a lifetime.

The Ocean Gallery Properties, Inc.

4600 Highway A1A South,
St. Augustine, Florida USA 32080

Information: (800) 398-5980
Reservations: (877) 542-2488
Local: (904) 471-6663
Fax: (904) 471-5994